
I've had a Sirius S50 receiver until just recently. It was the most persnickity piece of hardware ever. Crashing, seizing, intermittently not recording shows. A D- to its creators.
Yesterday, a lot of that changed when my wife got me the Sirius Stiletto 2 receiver (at the recommendation of my co-author Samuel Johnson). What follows is my initial review and a touch of public service/advice.
What you should know. I work in a high rise in Philadelphia so I rely on a terrestrial repeater for my office signal. With the S50, my signal was never a problem in the office. Right off the bat, the Stiletto 2 was dropping signal right and left. Totally unacceptable to a
Howard Stern and
Whatever addict.
So I pushed my Sirius antenna (which was attached to a Sirius Home Dock Kit SUPH1 -- more about this POS later) all over the place trying to get a better signal. The antenna didn't pick up shit. Fucking pissed off that the S50 got a much better signal--using the same antenna--I looked all over the Web for answers.
I found none but have solved or at least understand the problem. Apparently there are 4 ways to get a signal on the Stiletto. First, from the satellite. Second, through a direct Internet connection. Third, through a Wi-Fi connection. And fourth, through a terrestrial repeater. It's this fourth signal that I catch in my office because the tinted windows of my building block the satellite reception.
Oddly, the terrestrial antenna is not part of the square Sirius antenna. The Stiletto 2's terrestrial antenna is IN THE RECEIVER. So the closer I put the receiver to the window, the better the signal I receive. Problem solved, but fucking annoying that the receiver has a weaker terrestrial antenna than the S50.
Don't get me wrong. It's way better than the S50 that I had so I am happy with it. Still, here are some other major flaws:
(1) There are 2 home docking station options. 1, the SLH2, is sold out at every vendor. The other--the one I have (the SUPH1)--has no remote control so I have to be sitting on top of the player to do any function.
SUPH1

SLH2

(2) On the receiver, you can't scroll through channels without going 2 deep into the menus. (You can only scroll through the presets.) You should be able to channel scroll from the main screen.
(3) The pause "buffer" is only 60 minutes. With all the storage available, why not let the pause buffer be variable by the size available in the hard drive. Or let the user set the buffer size. I often have to pause my radio while I leave the office for more than 1 hour. It would be excellent if I could return to the office 3 hours later and pick up right where I left off.
(4) There is no way to stop the screen from dimming to save its energy. That is stupid. It's a small screen and when it's plugged in, I shouldn't have to keep tapping the screen when I want to see what's on.
All that said, the Stiletto 2 is a massive upgrade over the S50 and the blocky headphone antenna combo is great. The Wi-Fi is also fantastic.